Whats the best speaker dock for the iphone 3gs?

hello!

ive been researching these for a few days. i have one myself and i like it but im getting one for my parents for the holidays.

it needs to be compatible with the iphone 3gs and also charge the device.

here are the two i have been looking at:

http://www.amazon.com/Altec-Lansing-T612-Digital-Speaker/dp/B0014XKQY2/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=mp3&qid=1259788873&sr=1-1

&

http://www.amazon.com/iHome-iP9SR-Clock-iPhone-Silver/dp/B001L9KN56/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=mp3&qid=1259788903&sr=1-3

ones and altec lansing and ones an ihome.
i have an altec lansing right now.. but im not sure if ihomes are better.

im worried mostly about sound quality and the fact that it can charge.

what are your favorites? or.. which would you chose out of these two

Recommended Readings

• In Mobile Age, Sound Quality Steps Back | PDA-247
• MagiCAD 2009.11+SR-1+Crack x32.rar | Free downloads indexer
• Proshares Ultra Short QQQQ (QID): Playing the NASDAQ Pullback | FavStocks
• Yahoo! to open source floating Google-Amazon crossbreed – Cloud News | CloudTweaks.com
• 5th Day of QQQQ Short Term Down-trend; QID and Cash | Wishing Wealth Blog

Tagged with: 3gs • altec lansing • amazon • amp • clock • digital speaker • dp • few days • holidays • ihome • iphone • iphone sticker skins for iphone 3g of jay-z on ebay • parents • qid • s mp3 • sound quality • sr 1

Filed under: iPhone Dock